Deal-Hunting Guides

Refurbished Grades Explained: What Premium, Excellent, Good and Fair Mean

By Rowan KellerPublished Add as a preferred source on Google

Has been buying open-box and returned stock for over a decade, and built Warehouse Watcher to stop losing track of it.

Refurbished Grades Explained: What Premium, Excellent, Good and Fair Mean

Refurbished grades explained simply: a refurbished grade tells you how a device looks, not how it works. Every legitimate refurbisher tests each unit to perform like new, so the grade is a contract about cosmetics, scratches, dents and battery health, and nothing else.

The catch is that the words do not mean the same thing everywhere. An Excellent at Amazon Renewed means no visible damage from 12 inches away; an Excellent at Back Market means micro-scratches invisible from 8 inches. Here is how to read each program's labels so you pay for what you actually want, and never overpay for a grade.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, Warehouse Watcher earns from qualifying purchases. Product links below are affiliate links and don't change the price you pay. Learn more.

The only rule about refurbished grades

Every serious refurbisher grades the same thing: the outside. The inside is fixed. A phone graded Acceptable has to work exactly as well as one graded Premium, or it fails inspection and never gets listed. That is the one rule that makes the whole system legible.

So do not compare grade names across stores. Compare three things instead: who does the refurbishing (the manufacturer or a vetted third party), the warranty and return window, and whether the battery has a guaranteed floor. The cosmetics are the discount; the warranty is the safety net.

Amazon Renewed grades: Premium, Excellent, Good, Acceptable

Amazon Renewed is Amazon's program for pre-owned, refurbished and open-box electronics, on amazon.com, amazon.ca and its UK, German, French, Italian and Spanish stores. Items are inspected, cleaned and tested, then sold in one of four cosmetic grades, all fully functional:

  • Premium: no visible cosmetic damage when held 12 inches away, battery above 90% of original capacity, 365-day return window under the Renewed Guarantee.
  • Excellent: no visible damage at 12 inches, battery above 80%, 90-day return window.
  • Good: screen free of scratches, light body scratches barely visible at 12 inches and imperceptible to touch, battery above 80%, 90-day returns.
  • Acceptable: a few shallow screen scratches that vanish when the screen is on, visible body scratches, up to three minor dents, battery above 80%, 90-day returns.

Good and Acceptable are only sold for phones, tablets, smartwatches, headphones and computers, and accessories on the lower tiers may be generic rather than original-brand.

Verdict: Excellent is the sweet spot, near-new looks for a real markdown. Pay for Premium only if the 365-day return window matters, and touch Acceptable only for a device that will live in a case. Compare refurbished prices against the best deals on Amazon, and browse Amazon Renewed to see current pricing.

Apple Certified Refurbished: no grades, one standard

Apple is the odd one out: it does not grade at all. Every Apple Certified Refurbished device is tested to the same functional standards as a new one, ships with the same one-year limited warranty, and stays eligible for AppleCare+.

The standout detail is the battery. Refurbished iOS devices, iPhones and iPads, get a brand-new battery and a brand-new outer shell, so a refurbished iPhone looks and charges like new. Macs get genuine Apple replacement parts where inspection calls for them, no automatic new battery. Everything ships in a new white box with all accessories and 14-day returns in the US.

The tradeoff is the discount: Apple advertises savings of up to 15%, the smallest markdown here. Verdict: the safest refurbished buy for an iPhone or iPad, because nobody else hands you a new battery, but rarely the cheapest.

Back Market's refurbished grades: Premium, Excellent, Good, Fair

Back Market is a marketplace of vetted refurbishers, strongest in the US and across Europe, the UK, France, Germany, Spain and Italy, though it has no Canadian storefront. Four tiers for phones, tablets, laptops, desktops and smartwatches:

  • Premium: almost no signs of use, genuine manufacturer parts only, battery at or above 90% of original capacity.
  • Excellent: very light micro-scratches, invisible from 8 inches away; no scratches on the screen.
  • Good: light micro-scratches, invisible from arm's length, about 20 inches; no scratches on the screen.
  • Fair: visible scratches and dents that do not affect performance, light screen scratches that may show slightly when the display is on, possibly the previous owner's engraving.

Every grade is guaranteed fully functional with a battery floor of at least 80% of original capacity, backed by a one-year warranty and 30-day returns.

Verdict: Good is the smart buy, the no-screen-scratches line is where the cosmetic compromises start to vanish. Fair is genuinely good value for a beater phone or a kid's tablet; Premium makes sense when the device is a gift.

Best Buy and eBay refurbished grades, side by side

Best Buy sells returned and display models in the US and Canada (bestbuy.com and bestbuy.ca) under open-box grades. The top two tiers are the safe ones:

  • Excellent - Certified: Geek Squad inspected and certified, looks brand new with no visible flaws, all original parts and accessories included, and often keeps full manufacturer warranty coverage.
  • Excellent: looks brand new with minimal wear, tested and working, all essential accessories included.
  • Satisfactory: moderate cosmetic blemishes, screen intact and fully functional; original packaging typically missing and nonessential accessories may be gone.
  • Fair: heavy cosmetic wear, and vital accessories like a laptop power adapter may be missing, though the item still has to work.

eBay's program runs in the US, the UK and other markets with four tiers. Certified is the top: refurbished by the manufacturer or a manufacturer-approved vendor, pristine like-new condition, and in the US a two-year warranty serviced by Allstate with 30-day returns. Excellent, Very Good and Good step the cosmetics down, like-new, minimal wear, moderate wear, from vetted sellers with a one-year Allstate-backed warranty and 30-day returns. Note that plain "Seller Refurbished" is not part of this program; it is the seller's own claim under their own rules.

Verdict: on Best Buy, buy Excellent or Excellent-Certified and nothing lower, and note Excellent is often only around 10% cheaper than new, so compare it against Renewed prices first. On eBay, Certified's two-year warranty is the strongest coverage in refurbished retail, and the program grades are the only refurbished labels you can trust there.

Which refurbished grade should you actually buy?

Buy by use case and the choice makes itself:

  • iPhone or iPad you will keep for years: Apple Certified Refurbished. The new battery alone justifies it.
  • Best-value phone or tablet: Amazon Renewed Excellent, or Back Market Good if you are outside North America.
  • Cheapest working laptop or console: Renewed Acceptable or Back Market Fair, then put it in a case and forget the cosmetics.
  • A gift, or a device you will hand someone: Premium or Certified tiers only.
  • Warranty anxiety: eBay Certified in the US, with its two-year Allstate coverage, beats every other program.

One last check before you buy any refurbished grade: compare the price against new, and against open-box stock. Sometimes a Warehouse deals listing graded Used - Very Good undercuts every refurbished tier. WarehouseWatcher tracks open-box, sales and lightning deals across all seven of its country feeds, so scan the US deals, Canada deals and UK deals pages, plus Germany, France, Italy and Spain, before you lock in.

Frequently asked questions

Is a refurbished phone as good as a new one?

Functionally, yes, from any vetted program. Every unit is tested to work like new, so the only difference from a new device is cosmetic. That is exactly what the grade tells you: an Excellent or Premium unit will look close to new, while a Fair or Acceptable one will show its history.

Which refurbished grade is the best value?

The middle tier is almost always the sweet spot: Amazon Renewed Excellent or Back Market Good. You get near-new looks, a solid battery floor and a proper return window for meaningfully less than the top tier. The cheaper tiers only win when the device will live in a case.

Does buying refurbished affect the warranty?

It depends on who did the refurbishing. Apple ships a full one-year warranty, identical to new. eBay Certified carries a two-year warranty serviced by Allstate in the US. Amazon backs Renewed with its own return guarantee, and Back Market offers a one-year warranty. On open-box stock, some manufacturers only honor warranties for the original buyer, which our [Amazon Warehouse deals explained](/guides/warehouse-deals-explained) covers in detail.

Are Fair and Acceptable refurbished grades worth buying?

Yes, when the price gap is real. Fair and Acceptable units are fully functional by definition; you are trading scratches and scuffs for a lower price. For a phone that will live in a case, or a console tucked under a TV, the cosmetics barely matter and the savings do.

Can I trust any seller's "refurbished" label on eBay?

Not automatically. eBay's program grades are Certified, Excellent, Very Good and Good, and sellers must qualify to use them. A plain "Seller Refurbished" listing is the seller's own claim, outside the program, with the seller's own rules. Stick to the program grades.